AllTrails
Your guide to the outdoors
MapMagic
Route planner for explorers with real-time collaboration
Updated February 2026
| AllTrails | MapMagic | |
|---|---|---|
| Rating | 5.0★ | 4.6★ |
| Reviews | 3 | 15 |
| Pros | 0 | 11 |
| FactScore™ | 30.1 | 55 |
FactScore™ Comparison
FactScore™ weighs both quality (rating) and popularity (reviews) for a fairer ranking than stars alone.
Pros & Cons
Only in AllTrails — Pros
No unique pros listedBoth tools — Pros
—Only in MapMagic — Pros
Real-time collaboration POIs feature Automatic route calculation Route grouping Smart routing User-friendly interface Browser-based access Hiking maps Multi-day plans Offline maps Solid performanceOnly in AllTrails — Cons
—Both tools — Cons
—Only in MapMagic — Cons
Account deletion issues Aggressive onboarding Lack of mobile app Language localization issues Unprofessional support channelDetails
| AllTrails | MapMagic | |
|---|---|---|
| Categories | Hiking apps | Team collaboration software, Travel Planning, Maps and GPS, Hiking apps |
| Platforms | Web · iOS | Web |
| Became Popular | November 11, 2014 | March 24, 2023 |
| Website | www.alltrails.com | mapmagic.app |
Who Should Pick Which?
Choose AllTrails if...
- No unique pros listed
Choose MapMagic if...
- Real-time collaboration
- POIs feature
- Automatic route calculation
With a FactScore™ of 30.1 vs 55, MapMagic leads in community reception. AllTrails uniquely offers No unique pros listed, while MapMagic stands out for Real-time collaboration and POIs feature.
What Users Say
AllTrails
Love the filter feature and and beautiful photos submitted by other users. Wish there was another level to differentiate between hard and super hard :)
I love this. Best app to find trails and reviews of hiking trails
I love All Trails for finding hikes in areas I'm traveling to. Most of the hikes are accurately rated which makes it easier to prepare for them!
MapMagic
This look really neat. I love the idea of being able to save multiple routes so that they all don't bunch together, even in the same location. Do you know about how long it will take for an OS app ...
Handy! This kind of app has been missing for a long time. Often I'd want to explore an area and I know for a fact that many others are coming there with exact same purpose; there are sometimes even...
Manymap is a dream come true for adventure lovers! The multi-day plans and real-time collaboration features are just what explorers need to plan their next journey. The app is super user-friendly a...
Related Comparisons
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better, AllTrails or MapMagic?
Based on FactScore™, MapMagic leads with a score of 55 vs 30.1. MapMagic has a higher rating of 4.6★ compared to 5.0★.
What are the pros of AllTrails compared to MapMagic?
AllTrails uniquely offers: No unique pros listed.
What are the pros of MapMagic compared to AllTrails?
MapMagic uniquely offers: Real-time collaboration, POIs feature, Automatic route calculation, Route grouping, Smart routing.
Is AllTrails better rated than MapMagic?
AllTrails is rated 5.0★ from 3 reviews. MapMagic is rated 4.6★ from 15 reviews.
What is the FactScore™ of AllTrails and MapMagic?
FactScore™ weighs rating and review volume together. AllTrails scores 30.1 and MapMagic scores 55.
Don't Get Fooled by Fake Social Media Videos
The world's first fact checker for social media. Paste any link and get an instant credibility score with sources.
Try FactCheckTool Free