Black Magic
Show a progress bar on your Twitter profile picture
Ugly Duckling
Consistency on 𝕏 made easier.
Updated February 2026
| Black Magic | Ugly Duckling | |
|---|---|---|
| Rating | 4.4★ | 5.0★ |
| Reviews | 8 | 11 |
| Pros | 4 | 16 |
| FactScore™ | 41.8 | 54 |
FactScore™ Comparison
FactScore™ weighs both quality (rating) and popularity (reviews) for a fairer ranking than stars alone.
Pros & Cons
Only in Black Magic — Pros
Insights feature Analytics Feature updates Real-time bannerBoth tools — Pros
—Only in Ugly Duckling — Pros
Affordable pricing Beautiful design Simple analytics Insightful analytics Community leaderboard Motivational features No need for third-party tools 1-click export Appealing graphics Attractive analytics templates Chrome extension Easy to use Growth tracking Lifetime license Sharing features Simplified processOnly in Black Magic — Cons
Difficult navigation Login problems Outages Poor documentation Unresponsive supportBoth tools — Cons
—Only in Ugly Duckling — Cons
Limited to TwitterDetails
| Black Magic | Ugly Duckling | |
|---|---|---|
| Categories | Social media management tools, Social Networking, Twitter apps | Social media management tools, Chrome Extensions |
| Platforms | Web | Web |
| Became Popular | May 20, 2021 | May 31, 2023 |
| Website | blackmagic.so | uglyduckling.app |
Who Should Pick Which?
Choose Black Magic if...
- Insights feature
- Analytics
- Feature updates
Choose Ugly Duckling if...
- Affordable pricing
- Beautiful design
- Simple analytics
With a FactScore™ of 41.8 vs 54, Ugly Duckling leads in community reception. Black Magic uniquely offers Insights feature and Analytics, while Ugly Duckling stands out for Affordable pricing and Beautiful design.
What Users Say
Black Magic
A game changer, one of the best tools to supercharge Twitter.
cool
Good
Ugly Duckling
Twitter default analytics sucks! I needed something that could clearly show the growth of my account whenever I wanted to, while not sacrificing design. Ugly Duckling's simple analytics tool made i...
This is a genius idea. I used to pay $29.99/m for Blackmagic, but this takes your "native" Twitter Analytics and turns them into something that is usable for free or a one-time $9 for some pro feat...
I’d recommend this in a heartbeat. THIS IS AN AWESOME EXTENSION! I was dreading to go to the twitter analytics page. Seriously, has this been abandoned by the Twitter team? It looks like they launc...
Related Comparisons
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better, Black Magic or Ugly Duckling?
Based on FactScore™, Ugly Duckling leads with a score of 54 vs 41.8. Ugly Duckling has a higher rating of 5.0★ compared to 4.4★.
What are the pros of Black Magic compared to Ugly Duckling?
Black Magic uniquely offers: Insights feature, Analytics, Feature updates, Real-time banner.
What are the pros of Ugly Duckling compared to Black Magic?
Ugly Duckling uniquely offers: Affordable pricing, Beautiful design, Simple analytics, Insightful analytics, Community leaderboard.
Is Black Magic better rated than Ugly Duckling?
Black Magic is rated 4.4★ from 8 reviews. Ugly Duckling is rated 5.0★ from 11 reviews.
What is the FactScore™ of Black Magic and Ugly Duckling?
FactScore™ weighs rating and review volume together. Black Magic scores 41.8 and Ugly Duckling scores 54.
Don't Get Fooled by Fake Social Media Videos
The world's first fact checker for social media. Paste any link and get an instant credibility score with sources.
Try FactCheckTool Free