Magical
Make tasks disappear. Like magic.
Shepherd
Meeting notes, agendas & tasks - in Google Calendar & Meet
Updated February 2026
| Magical | Shepherd | |
|---|---|---|
| Rating | 4.9★ | 5.0★ |
| Reviews | 20 | 17 |
| Pros | 10 | 21 |
| FactScore™ | 64.1 | 62.8 |
FactScore™ Comparison
FactScore™ weighs both quality (rating) and popularity (reviews) for a fairer ranking than stars alone.
Pros & Cons
Only in Magical — Pros
Time saving Automation of repetitive tasks Easy setup Productivity improvement Keyboard shortcuts Customer support Text expansion AI features Chrome extension Variables featureBoth tools — Pros
—Only in Shepherd — Pros
Improved meeting productivity Easy to use Collaborative notes Time-saving Easy note sharing Google Meet integration Meeting minutes capture Fast product improvement Google Calendar integration Meeting notes storage No multi-tabs Productivity app integrations Remote team collaboration Structure meetings Agenda management Assign action items Custom agendas Email sharing Export to Notion Streamlined processes Task allocationOnly in Magical — Cons
Suggestion window Customer support Desktop extension Firefox support Shortcut reliability Shortcut sharingBoth tools — Cons
—Only in Shepherd — Cons
Lack of home page for previous meeting notesDetails
| Magical | Shepherd | |
|---|---|---|
| Categories | Productivity, Automation tools, Chrome Extensions | Productivity, Chrome Extensions, Meeting software |
| Platforms | Web | Web |
| Became Popular | June 6, 2022 | March 3, 2022 |
| Website | www.getmagical.com | www.meetshepherd.com |
Who Should Pick Which?
Choose Magical if...
- Time saving
- Automation of repetitive tasks
- Easy setup
Choose Shepherd if...
- Improved meeting productivity
- Easy to use
- Collaborative notes
With a FactScore™ of 64.1 vs 62.8, Magical leads in community reception. Magical uniquely offers Time saving and Automation of repetitive tasks, while Shepherd stands out for Improved meeting productivity and Easy to use.
What Users Say
Magical
I don't know how many keystrokes this extension has saved me over the years, but it's got to be in the millions.
Great, innovative product! I can't wait to see what AI brings into the mix at Magical
Amazing time saving tool for me and my company
Shepherd
Amazing product, I especially love taking meeting notes and exporting to Notion with a click. Also love the integrations.
I use shepherd as an individual and not necessarily with my team as they are all very much physical presence meeting people. This product has helped structure my thoughts before and during meetings...
I have been an early user of Shepherd for a few weeks now, and it has already improved the meetings I host. It helps with ensuring an agenda before a meeting, because I have a clear place in my cal...
Related Comparisons
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better, Magical or Shepherd?
Based on FactScore™, Magical leads with a score of 64.1 vs 62.8. Magical has a higher rating of 4.9★ compared to 5.0★.
What are the pros of Magical compared to Shepherd?
Magical uniquely offers: Time saving, Automation of repetitive tasks, Easy setup, Productivity improvement, Keyboard shortcuts.
What are the pros of Shepherd compared to Magical?
Shepherd uniquely offers: Improved meeting productivity, Easy to use, Collaborative notes, Time-saving, Easy note sharing.
Is Magical better rated than Shepherd?
Magical is rated 4.9★ from 20 reviews. Shepherd is rated 5.0★ from 17 reviews.
What is the FactScore™ of Magical and Shepherd?
FactScore™ weighs rating and review volume together. Magical scores 64.1 and Shepherd scores 62.8.
Don't Get Fooled by Fake Social Media Videos
The world's first fact checker for social media. Paste any link and get an instant credibility score with sources.
Try FactCheckTool Free